Do you believe Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of Art? If so, what makes it Art in your opinion. If not, please give an example of another building that you feel is truly artistic. Please include a link to the image of the building and an explanation of why you feel it is a work of Art.
The Baha'i Temple in Wilmette is a work of art. The architecture is stunning and the content of the architecture is how the Baha'is represent their faith to non- Baha'is. Both the exterior and the adjoining gardens were created for both Baha'is and others to understand and appreciate the faith of the Baha'is.
ReplyDeleteLINK: http://www.google.com/imgres?um=1&hl=en&sa=N&biw=1366&bih=622&tbm=isch&tbnid=t4uq7utoVyigJM:&imgrefurl=http://activerain.com/blogsview/1170848/architecturally-interesting-baha-i-temple-chicago&docid=r-MrNBtFhagbOM&imgurl=http://activerain.com/image_store/uploads/9/2/7/7/5/ar124879553857729.jpg&w=675&h=506&ei=Il8sUJrnKubDyAHWlIG4Aw&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=518&vpy=144&dur=20&hovh=194&hovw=259&tx=111&ty=79&sig=108204565044006995209&page=1&tbnh=128&tbnw=188&start=0&ndsp=19&ved=1t:429,r:2,s:0,i:82
I believe Brunelleschi's dome is absolutely a work of art. I don't think art is juat limited to certain things such as paintings, sculptures, and drawings, I believe it can extend to architecture as well. The aspect that I think most distinguishes it as art is the technique used to make it. It was truly a work of art when he had to arrange the bricks a certian way or the sandstone chain was built around the dome. To me, Architecture is just a more advanced form of art. It takes skill to devise the plans and create the structure just as it takes skill to paint or to draw. An aspect that I think contributes to it being a work of art is the brickwork of the herringbone technique. The technique is difficult and intricate. Also art is defined as the quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance. The dome was definetly aesthetic appealing and was of more than ordinary significance. People from all of Florence admired the dome while it was being built and now people around the world admire it. Art takes technique and passion, which are two things Brunelleschi had plenty of, and he built the dome with a passion for it to make a differnece in the world. And today it has become one of the most renowned structures of all time and affects people's lives by its beauty. That is why the dome is considered art.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. It was new and extraordinary for its time. It is a work of art because of the design it took to be made. I believe that something which is thought up and planned out and built as Brunelleschi's dome was, is a work of art. It is ultimately a big sculpture and sculptures are art. The "sculpture" was built up from the base all the way up to the lantern structure on the top of the dome. Clearly, the design and the building of the dome is art because it is a big sculpture.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this great novel I have concluded that Brunelleschi's dome is no doubt an amazing work of art. The dome is art because in order to complete such a great puzzlement, one man was needed to shed his brilliance so that the lifelong dream of a completed dome could be done. This dome is also art because the designs inside and out of the dome are incredible. But I think that it is most like art because of the struggle to accomplish the work including problems with making perfect bricks, finding a way to raise the bricks to the level needed, and fighting an illness that could have taken the life of a person. But no. Filippo Brunelleschi found a way to overcome everything. Filippo battled the "brick problem" by asking for various shapes and sizes of the bricks and he was said to have inspected every single brick before letting it through. Filippo also found his way around the problem of raising the material and placing it perfectly by creating an ox-hoist never seen before. Finally, Filippo faught the hardest feat of all which nearly killed him. Just while Lorenzo started taking his place and changed things, Filippo made a miraculous recovery from his illness and immediately took control again of the project leading it to its completion. For these reasons I find that this dome of the Santa Maria del Fiore was truly a magnificent work of art.
ReplyDeleteEdgar Degas once said, "Art is not what you see, but what you make others see."
ReplyDeleteAs a distorter of reality and master of perspective, Filippo inspired Florence and the rest of the world through his completion of the dome at Santa Maria del Fiore. Being a technological innovator, Brunelleschi made the bold decision to challenge himself through the construction of the dome's design and overall completion. This involved the creation of ideas such as the ox-hoist, stone chains, or herringbone patterns. While the dome itself captures the essence of art, the dome is a piece of art for another reason. Filippo's intellectual thinking was inspiration for many other fields. For example, Brunelleschi transformed architecture into an art demanding of great skill and thinking power. Brunelleschi's dome provoked others to see innovation and creativity within themselves, and for this reason, it is a piece of art.
Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. At first, I thought it was creative, intimidating, and lovely in its own way. Honestly speaking though, I did not really see it as a piece of art. It looked worn out, plain, and just tall; it was only a building to me. But after reading and following the multiple years and hundreds of people who put their soul into creating this one building I feel that the dome became a work of art. When thinking about what art is, it really depends on the person because art could mean a picture that inspires or surprises you. Other forms of art could be a piece that can be relatable, alien/new, or it could be really simple but mean the world to that person. For me, I was able to see that the dome was a treasure to the people of Florence. I admit also seeing the interior surface of the dome that I was blown away with all of its detailed/brilliant designs (pictures) all devoted to faith.
ReplyDeleteBruunelleschi's dome was a work of art. He and many others painstakingly created a dome that soared high into the sky and filled those who saw it with hope for mankind and pride in mankind's accomplishment. Every inch of the Dome is filled with the builders efforts and the planners' dreams that, when brought together, can leave people rather in awe of the Dome. This is because art is made up of emotion, it contains the emotion of the artist in addition to what the art shows and the emotion it creates it those who see it. As a result when people see the Dome somehow the care and work of thousands of people seems to seep though and leaves the viewer with feelings of pride and hope. The sight invokes emotion of the viewer making it art the that person. The reason several geniuses have worked on the Dome or come to see it is because it is art and it is inspiring.
ReplyDeletehttp://cache.virtualtourist.com/4/5804940-Cupola_from_ground_floor_Duomo_Florence_Italy_Florence.jpg
I do believe that Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. The amount of effort and the endless process that went into creating the dome resulted in a truly remarkable building. I believe that art is any work that involves creativity and thought and Brunelleschi's Dome certainly meets this requirement. The endless planning involving designs for the building itself and designs for building equipment shows the deep thought and creativity that the "artists" of the dome put forth. The artists of the building include anybody who used ingenuity and innovation to add to the creative process and in this case, many artists were needed. In addition, I believe that all art has a form of beauty whether it is beauty in significance or beauty in appearance. I think that the dome is beautiful in terms of appearance with its massive structure and intricate decoration and marble work. However, it also has beauty in significance and meaning with its role as a church in Florence. In conclusion, I believe that Brunelleschi’s Dome was not only an incredible architectural feat, but also a work of art.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.google.com/imgres?q=el+duomo+de+santa+maria&start=100&um=1&hl=en&safe=active&client=safari&sa=N&rls=en&biw=1920&bih=1040&tbm=isch&tbnid=Wms52C6ibBIgAM:&imgrefurl=http://members.virtualtourist.com/m/p/m/211e45/&docid=_h2EfDKqKnFjuM&imgurl=http://cache.virtualtourist.com/4/5804940-Cupola_from_ground_floor_Duomo_Florence_Italy_Florence.jpg&w=658&h=492&ei=lGUsUIP_BcibyAGIoYGADA&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=191&vpy=155&dur=86&hovh=194&hovw=260&tx=88&ty=155&sig=103446786273799510122&page=3&tbnh=164&tbnw=202&ndsp=51&ved=1t:429,r:8,s:100,i:128
ReplyDeleteThe dome of Santa Maria del Fiore is truly a work of art. Art is expression through specific mediums. Filipo was a truly gifted and unique artist and architect, with a mind for the impossible. Many concepts of his, including the spring-loaded clock, were way ahead of their time, and wouldn't appear for another 100 years. His ideas that went into the creation of the dome were expressive of his genius and intellect, qualities that set him apart from many involved in the same profession.The advanced machinery and building techniques were never before seen in the world of that time, and astonishingly revolutionary. His expression was in these concepts and ideas that were put into practice. He showed the world his capabilities and intellectual strength through his art.
ReplyDeleteI do believe that the Santa Maria del Fiore was indeed a work of art. I believe this because of the remarkable size, beauty, and the technology it possesses. "In height and span the cupola of Santa Maria del Fiore has never really been surpassed,". Other architects have tried to equal and surpass the size of the dome but none had succeeded until the twentieth century using modern materials. The dome described in this book is beautifully decorated and built. The many aspects of the dome, like the windows and the frescos, along with the wonderful building materials used, such as the lovely wood and bricks, both contribute to the beauty of the dome. Likewise, the view from the top of the dome, revealing Florence, is another example of the beauty. Brunelleschi and others working on the dome faced many challenges; however, they overcame these struggles and were able to build an amazing piece of architecture. The new design used, as well as the inventions used in the building, created an enormous and beautiful work of art. I think because of the beauty, size, and originality of thought used to build it, this dome is truly a work of art.
ReplyDeleteI believe Brunelleschi's dome was a work of art. The dome was innovative, stunning, and pure genius. It was visually appealling but at the same time structurally sound. In my opinion a work of art is the creation of something original but at the same time beautiful and inspiring. Brunelleschi's dome exemplifies both of those qualities. His dome became a landmark in Florence and will never be forgotten.
ReplyDeleteArt, in my opinion, is any creative and original work that not only inspires others but also challenges them to think. Brunelleschi's Dome is a prime example of the idea I have for what art is. Fhilippo's plan of an uncentered dome was such an original, risky, and unheard of thing for the time period. Once built, this massive structure confused so many spectators as to how the dome was supported. The mystery and newness of the building was and is still intriguing. Brunelleschi's Dome also inspired and affected all later architecture. It challenged others to build structures just as monumental in size and in creativity. Even though a building might not be the most obvious type of art, the creative and inspiring Santa Maria del Fiore is a perfect example of purely great art.
ReplyDeleteA work of art is an imaginative innovation that is appealing both aesthetically and creatively. I believe that Brunelleschi’s dome is a true work of art that exemplifies this definition. This dome is imaginative because of the countless revolutionary inventions and techniques that Brunelleschi used to create and build this masterpiece. Among other things, he did not support the dome by wooden centering, which was unheard of at the time, and he also made it octagonal and pointed rather than the traditional round dome. In addition, Brunelleschi’s dome is has a beautiful outward appearance. From its white marble ribs to the contrasting red, crosshatched bricks to the cupola on top, this dome is tasteful, symmetric, and well thought-out in its aesthetics. Brunelleschi’s creative genius is portrayed in this masterpiece, which in my opinion is a beautiful work of art for the ages.
ReplyDeleteMy personal belief is that Brunelleschi's dome was and is a work of art. The dome itself was mysteriously beautiful as it's structure was so ahead of his time! I also believe that you have created something wonderful when people start to try and bring you down. Brunelleschi had a numerous amount of enemies trying to steal his ideas or overshadow them. Another thing is Brunelleschi had to conjure up so many new ideas to build his dome! He was a master thinker and builder. His thinking and building led him to produce a stunningly massive dome that towers over even modern day domes.
ReplyDeleteI believe Brunelleschi’s Dome is indeed a work of art. In my opinion, it is not only
ReplyDeletethe final construction of this cathedral that makes it worthy of admiration, but the process in which it was constructed.. It is unimaginable to think of the amount of material that was used to raise the dome without a center. Due to the symmetrical construction of the dome, it appeals to the eye of the general public. It is also greatly admired by many engineers and architects because of the way in which it was built, having the inner shell supporting the outer shell while still maintaining its interior proportions. Brunelleschi’s dome is then not only a work of art from an aesthetics perspective, but also because of the way it was designed and built. The interior of the dome with a tridimensional perspective on a two dimensional surface is impressive. The images on the ceiling of the dome which are made entirely of mosaic paintings only add another factor to why this building is a work of art.
Fillipo Brunelleschi built a masterpiece of a dome. The dome was constructed as an equisite work of art that was beautiful, impressive and helped stimulate major advances in astronomy and navigation. The large slabs of the marble in which the dome is adorned make the dome a place of beauty and it is impressive because it was built without any centering creating a sense of mystery and wonder. The very impressed Leon Battista Alberti refered to the dome as, "an enormous consruction towering above the heavens...and done without the aid of beams or elaborate wooden supports." Also, one of Brunelleschi's friends named Paolo Toscanelli instigated major advances in astrononmy and navigation with the help of the dome. By placing a bronze plate at the center base of the lantern, he created a sundial. This sundial helped Toscanelli learn about the motions of the sun and then fix important structures such as the Alfonsine tables, which helped navigatiors and astronomers pinpoint lunar and solar eclipses, the Pole Star and the positions of the sun. Also, Toscanelli devised maps for Christopher Colombus' voyage to India, which instead lead him the New World. Toscanelli believes that the dome helped him create these maps for Colombus. The dome absolutely serves a work of art as it was not only an impressive, beautiful structure, but affected the world through advances in navigation and astronomy.
ReplyDeleteI do believe Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art because of its great size and the innovative techniques used to build it. In my opinion, the dome is a work of art because it inspired many other artists including da Vinci to build incredible works. The dome was very well made and its height was much larger than some of today's monumental domes like the Capitol in Washington, DC. Besides using no centering to build the dome and creating the ox hoist, Brunelleschi placed a plate of bronze in the middle of the lantern and created a sundial. This sundial was used by Toscanelli to make important scientific discoveries. In conclusion, Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art because it symbolizes the creativity and big dreams of artists and inventors. The dome towered above the streets of Florence so that all the citizens could see the greatness and power of the beautiful dome.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Brunelleshi's dome is a work of art, because of the time and effort. The dome is a masterpiece not only for the era it was built in, but for all generations. The difficulties of the dome had to be overcome by technologies that could not be repeated for centuries.
ReplyDeleteWritten By: Jack Nichols
I believe Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art because of the difficulty of the building project. Also, all the time put in to build the dome to the specific outline of the dome shows that it's a work of art. Lastly, all of the inventions made to build the dome shows all the effort put into making it a work of art.
ReplyDeleteWritten by: Ellen Conway
I feel that the dome of the cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore is truly one of humanity's greatest artistic achievments. There are many factors contributing to its beauty and awe. The sheer size alone of the octagonal dome towering over Florence is breathtaking. The ingenious architectural strategies that Brunelleschi implented in its creation also add to its wonder. The dome's other accessories, such as the lantern set at its summit, the terra cotta outer tiling, and the marvelous paintwork on the dome's interior contribute even more to this fantastic creation. Works of art such as the dome of the church of Santa Maria del Fiore are rarely surpassed in terms of artwork, style, and overall architecture.
ReplyDeleteWritten by Tom Dreher
I believe that Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art because of the the challenge it presented and because of the art work enmeshed in it. The outter shell of the dome is covered in art work and the inside church is full of relics, statues, and elaborate designs. Also, the difficulty in building it, the masterful architecture, and the excellent craftsmenship make it a work of art.
ReplyDeleteI wholeheartedly believe that Brunelleschi's dome is a revolutionary work of art. In order to construct the dome, Filippo had to embrace new inventions and techniques. He used his master craftmanship and eye for artistry to create a breathtakingly beautiful dome. It was built in and is covered in elaborate designs, such as the herringbone pattern (not to mention the fact that the inside is now covered in paintings.) The skillset used by Brunelleschi and the construction designs determine that dome is most certainly an artistic masterpiece that towers above all others- literally.
ReplyDeleteI think a work of art is something that someone worked on to make it beautiful. A work of art is something that people would go and see just to look upon its beauty. This is exactly what the dome is. And not only is it beautiful, but it revolutionized art and architecture altogether. The amazing and genius design is enough to take your breath away, but also to know how it was created without mostly any support, using almost only friction keeping the bricks together, I would think that that would just heighten the experience. That is what I think makes the dome a true work of art.
ReplyDeleteI believe Brunelleschi's dome is a great work of art. One of the reasons why it is a work of art is simply because it is so large, and for using the resources available in the 1400s it is amazing that it was even built. It also is a great work of art because it has no visible support system, so it creates the illusion that it is supported by nothing. Brunelleschi uses ingenious inventions such as herringbone brickwork and sandstone rings around the inside to create this illusion. He really showed off the massive dome by using no flying buttresses or wooden centering systems to distract from its beauty. The dome was decorated with different types of marble which also added artistic flair to it. Artists painted wonderful artwork on the inside of the dome as well, which Ross King describes as "The Nest of Delights". Brunelleschi's Dome is definitely a work of Art inside and out.
ReplyDeleteThe phrase “work of art,” is defined as “a product that gives aesthetic pleasure and that can be judged separately from any utilitarian considerations.” (According to dictionary.com) Given this definition I can logically conclude that Brunelleschi’s Dome is a work of art. But art is in the eye of the beholder, and must be judged likewise. In my opinion, art is a physical substance that shows beauty or expresses emotion. Brunelleschi’s Dome is art because it is a beautiful building and a remarkable architectural feat. There is no church quite comparable to the wonder that is the Santa Maria del Fiore. Fillipo’s dome had more contributions that visual appeal, it also served scientific purposes. The dome aided mapmakers and astronomers in navigation, which prompted Toscanelli to create a new world map and inspired Christopher Columbus to sail west in an attempt to reach India. Fillipo was rightfully considered an artistic genius. “’Genius’ a term invented by the Italian humanist philosophers to describe a natural ability for original invention.” (p. 159)
ReplyDeleteI believe that Brunelleschi's dome is in fact a work of art. I believe this because his dome was not just any ordinary dome. There were intricate patterns and designs used to not only make sure the dome would stay up and standing, but to make sure that it looked beautiful and complimented the rest of the church as well. A work of art i believe is anything that someone designs with purpose, creativity, and has an end result that leads people to think more about that piece of art. Brunelleschi accomplished all those things and his dome to this day continues to leave people with a sense of wonder and awe at this amazing piece of art- his dome.
ReplyDeleteHaving seen Brunelleschi's most famous work in person on a trip to Italy, I would say that indeed, his most famous work of architecture is a great masterpiece to be adored for generations. It accomplishes the idea that the builders were originally striving to make reality: the dome reaching high into the clouds in order to simulate man's ascent toward heaven and God. Moreover, it continues to hold its title as the world's largest dome today. However, most importantly in my opinion at least, the dome is able to make one feel something when one looks upon it, which is the purpose of art itself. Gazing at it, it almost appears as though powers both human and divine joined to create such a magnificent structure. It is incredibly astounding that one man's idea could give birth to something so grand and beautiful. Because Brunelleschi's dome evokes such emotions, I would say that it is one of the world's most fantastic architectural works of art.
ReplyDeleteI believe Brunelleschi's Dome is a beautiful piece of exquiste artwork that was the start of a new era, an era were architecture was viewed as an art form. Brunellleschi's brought fresh ideas that challenged what was believed possible during his time. His dome inspired others to push the boundries and try to build unique beautiful buildings as a form of art. This dome helped inspire amazing artists such as Michangelo and Leonardo da Vinci. As well as inspiring other artists, the dome inspired astronomers and navigators. Paolo Toscanelli placed a sundial in the church by placing a broze plate in the center of the lantern. This sundial helped him identify more accurately the positions of the sun along with lunar and solar eclipses. This sun dial allowed Paolo Toscanelli to draw up more accurate maps of navigators like Christopher Columbus. The level of detail that Brunelleschi gives this dome is truly what makes it a spectacular masterpiece. Everything is so intricate, from the way it was built with no wooden centering to the beautiful materials that were used.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's dome was the most innovative piece of art created during that time period. Filippo's determination to complete the dome, even though people told him it wouldn't work, is what makes this piece even more astounding. The detail that went into creating the dome is unbelievable. The art inside the dome is breathtaking in its own right, but the persistence of Filippo to continue to build the dome, even when it seemed impossible is what is astounding to me. I believe that art can make something stick out of the crowd. Brunelleschi's Dome did that because it towered over every other building. Filippo put his own design and own plan into this structure, which makes it more impressive. He didn't want to have any visible supports because he wanted whoever entered into the dome to see the entire beauty of the structure. It is overall a very impressive building and the fact it was made centuries ago is shocking.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's Dome was most definitely a work of art because of the creativity and time put into creating this masterpiece. Art can't only be a structured picture on a canvas, it comes in all shapes and forms. It can come in sculptures, music, buildings, and many other things that surround us everyday. This building was art because of the way it was put together and the amount of ingenuity and design needed to fulfill the project. Brunelleschi did not simply build a dome, he designed the layout using new ideas and it wasn't just a dome of concrete, it had designs and a style to it that made it look like a work of art. He designed the whole thing himself and made sure everything ran smoothly and according to plan. The amount of creativity, risk, and effort Brunelleschi put into the dome is astonishing. When you see the finished dome, it is hard not to believe something as detailed and intricate as that is not a wok of art.
ReplyDeleteI believe Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. Art is more than just pictures and paintings, it's a form of expression. Not only was the structure of the Dome beautiful and one of a kind but it expressed the engineering genius that Filippo was. He portrayed this in the brilliant way he designed, made and finished the dome - solving a complex problem in a unique, never-been-tried before way. It is beautiful on the inside and out, and inspired others to build more things as magnificent as this dome, which is indeed a stunning work of art.
ReplyDeleteI do believe Brunelleschi's Dome was a work of art. In my opinion art can be anything that took time and thought to be made, used creativity and that some people can see as beautiful. The Dome of Santa Maria del Fiore definitely fits into my definition because the dome took almost 20 years to construct and the thoughts of many were used in the process of putting together the dome's construction, even though Brunelleschi was a key genius in making this all happen. The dome had to be thought of being built in a new creative manner because of the size of the dome. Filippo had this creativity in mind and came up with solutions to the domes many problems of vaulting without centering and used the herringbone brick pattern and the nine rings to solve these problems. Many people from around the world come to see the dome and it's beautiful and artistic structure.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's Dome is most certainly a work of art for the dedication put forth in order to create the perfection of the opus. Most people before Brunelleschi's time did not believe architecture as a form of art. However, during Filippo's lifetime, architecture had been becoming more appreciated, especially after Brunelleschi's masterpiece. It is art because it shows parts of many different people's lives, mostly all the men who had worked on the Dome for years and years. Not only was the cathedral and edifice, but the whole church was in fact an art piece. Every place had fine decorative detailing making the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore one of the greatest works of art ever.
ReplyDeleteI do believe Filippo Brunelleschi's dome is art. The type of art he brings life to is an art form which many did not consider as a "noble occupation" (Ross, 158). He reinvents architecture and changes it from being just "mechanical" and "into a liberal art" (Ross,158). His dome is art not only in its use of cutting edge techniques, pure ingenuity, sheer beauty and awesome vastness but also in the way sets a up a revolution for more liberal thinkers and inspired onlookers to follow. That is what true art is; it helps people feel and inspires them do or make things that they did not even know they were capable of creating. Art also is a form of expression. Filippo expresses very well in his dome that he was serious about making a dome without wood centering. He was serious in his quest for perfection as he builds this impeccably perfect dome. He was serious about glorifying the city of Florence through this magnificent and awe-inspiring dome which is beautiful both inside and out. In his dome, Filippo expresses a sense of seriousness which is both dazzling and powerful. Through his seriousness in this grandiose piece of art, Filippo reenergizes following generations to be inspired by what they see and helps these generations to see that there are many forms of art and one is no less than the other.
ReplyDeleteI believe the dome was a work of art. I think art is a way of expressing oneself. I believe that Brunelleschi expressed himself in this dome by using creativity in the constuction of it as well as all of the time and dedication he put into the dome. The dome is a masterpiece and should be considered one by everyone.
ReplyDeleteI believe Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. Just looking at the finished product itself, one can see the beauty of it at a single glance. Then looking deeper into the story of the dome, the hard work put into the dome by the workers and Brunelleschi himself, one can appretiate the dome's beauty even more because one would know the sacrifice that went into it.
ReplyDeleteIn my poinion, a work of art is a art piece made from dedication and skill to express oneself or people. Art can be used to appeal or inspire perople too; in the case of Brunelleschi's dome I think it does both. The Santa Maria Del Fiore exemplifies the time and skill put into the dome through the interior paintings, the exterior details, the size of it, and the structure. The dome has inspired many by defying past building by making a large dome without wood centering and visibe flying buttresses. The dome allowed atronomers and navigator to make accomplishment also by studying off the top of the dome, later inspiring the creation of a new world map also. In addition to inspiring the people it is also visualy appealing because of the great artistic talent put into it and the size of the dome. The Santa Maria Del Fiore is truely a work of art. Link: http://www.google.com/imgres?um=1&hl=en&sa=N&rlz=1T4ADFA_enUS458US458&biw=1366&bih=589&tbm=isch&tbnid=k1PEmLmbtKxb_M:&imgrefurl=http://www.paradoxplace.com/Perspectives/Italian%2520Images/Montages/Firenze/Florence%2520Skylines.htm&docid=5om5CIUSAu7ZfM&imgurl=http://www.paradoxplace.com/Perspectives/Italian%252520Images/images/Firenze/Firenze_Skylines/900/Florence-Duomo-Nov07-RAW4827AR900.jpg&w=900&h=588&ei=V40tUOWOCIOFywGKooBQ&zoom=1&iact=hc&vpx=370&vpy=76&dur=1009&hovh=181&hovw=278&tx=169&ty=86&sig=104637587833446051921&page=1&tbnh=128&tbnw=171&start=0&ndsp=26&ved=1t:429,r:3,s:0,i:84
ReplyDeleteI believe that Brunelleschi’s dome is truly a work of art. Art is not just something that you sketch or paint, but rather a way to express ones talents in a way that others can see. In this case, Filippo used his skills as an engineer to produce this different work of art for all to enjoy. Both the inside and outside of the Santa Maria del Fiore were works of art. The outside shows Brunelleschi’s attention to detail and design. The inside of the dome, or the skeleton, shows great craftsmanship and preciseness. After seeing the dome in person, in addition to reading the book, I can say that this dome is a great work of art.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the dome at Santa Maria del Fiore is a work of art. Art is appealing to the eye, took time and imagination to create, pushed boundaries, and is unique to the artist. The dome was one of a kind at the time, and paved the way for future artists to design similar but no where as close to as beautiful replicas. The creativity Fillipo had when creating the dome is so original and beautiful to the eye that it has to be art. Brunelleschi's dome fits all of the qualifications, and can therefore be considered a work of art.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, art is a form of expression. Art is a tool through which, along with creativity and imagination, artists produce something that is beautiful or reflects something they see or feel. Following this understanding of the term, Brunelleschi’s Dome is definitely art. It was created, using specific skills and training, to be a thing of beauty, a precise, imposing architectural feat that the city of Florence could be proud of. Not only is it covered in elaborate patterns and designs, the inside of the dome is also decorated with beautiful paintings, statues, and religious figures.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Brunelleschi’s dome was a work of art. In my opinion, art is derivative of creative thought and that thought can be conveyed in infinite ways. Art is also constantly changing. Artists go against the norm and new methods evolve over time. Art allows for change. The dome of Santa Maria del Fiore fits all of these criteria. Brunelleschi pushed the limits of the artistic imagination of the time and created an innovative and massive architectural feat. Filippo went against the norm and used new techniques in creating the dome. His work forever changed and impacted architecture.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. In my opinion, art is unique and original. Brunellechi came up with many original ideas and was the first ever to successfully design and construct a dome of that size. Artists create new techniques and styles that make an impact on the world. Brunelleschi is an artist because he introduced the world to many new machines and building techniques that had never been used before. An artist incorporates all of their ideas into their design and doesn't stop working on it until it is exactly right. This process takes time, dedication, and passion, all of which were evident in Brunelleschi's work on the dome.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's Dome is definitely a work of art. Art can be expressed in many ways. It is not only the beautiful architecture that makes the dome a work of art, but also the construction and technique behind it. Every detail of the dome, whether visible today or its methods of construction years ago proves it is a work of art. The Dome stands as a symbol that art can be seen and created in many different ways.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's dome was a magnificant work of art. Art is a pleasure to the human eyes, so in my opinion, Brunnelleshci's dome is a fine work of art. He brought his drawn out plans to real life to create a stunning work of art. The dome is beautiful and creative as well as genious in terms of structure. The dome's size and design are breathtaking itself, and the interior design just adds to the beauty. Brunneleschi's dome is one of the greatest works of art ever seen.
ReplyDeleteI definitely think that Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. Art to me is when the artist uses his own creative skill and imagination and applys it to his creation. The Dome's structure and technique used was original and had not been used before. Also, the designs inside the dome and on the outside of it are unique and beautiful. They catch people's eyes as they are truely intrigued by the intricate paintings and forms. The Dome at Santa Maria del Fiore is an amazing work of art that is a joy to behold.
ReplyDeleteI do believe Filippo Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. I believe anyone who puts that time and effort into that kind of structure, is truly inspired and committed. I think that Filippo never gave up when he was put down, which shows how talented he is and how lucky we are to have something that well thought out and built at that time period to look at. I think the details he put into the building of the dome to the scientific structure is all a work of art, because when you are looking at the dome you not only think of religious thoughts, you think of what a pretty sight it really is. Many competitors of Filippo even tried to steal his own ideas because of how creative and beautiful his ideas and models were. I do think all of Filippo's hard work and creativity really show how great of a work of art his dome really is.
ReplyDeleteI do believe Brunelleschi's Dome is a true work of art. It required much planning and many people to build it. He put so much effort into designing and overseeing the building of the dome. The dome was not only admired then, but is still admired today. You experience his art differently because you can see it in front of you. It is incredible, just the sheer size of the dome, let alone the detail. Filippo was truly an amazing artist.
ReplyDeleteI do believe that Filippo Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. Art is something that is original and has an affect on a person upon seeing it. The dome is beautiful, magnificent, and no one had ever thought of creating it. It changed the path of architecture forever. No one thought they could build it, but with the inventions of new tools and with the great minds that helped build it, they created something the world had never seen before.
ReplyDeleteI do believe Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. The extremely intricate and ornate architecture of the dome clearly defines it as art in my opinion. The dome could have been made to look much simpler, however Filippo and the Opera went above and beyond to make the Dome a magnificent work of art. Another reason I consider the Dome a work of art is its sheer size. The Dome is in effect part of the roof of a church, and it was not necessary to build it as large as Filippo did. All of Florence wanted the Dome to be so massive because they wanted a beautiful and awe inspiring work of art in the city. The architecture and size of Brunelleschi's Dome combine to form a moving sight, and it is definitely art.
ReplyDeleteI think that Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. It's a beautiful structure to look at with elements such as polished marble and bricks layed in a herringbone pattern. These elements arre important to the integrety of the dome, as well as enhancing to the esthetic of the dome. On top of the dome, a marble lantern tops it to provide light, but it also makes the dome more attractive. Also, the dome is a masterpiece because of the higher level of thought that went into it's design. Filippo solved the enigma of making a dome bigger than any other, and at the same time, he managed to completely reinvent the construction of domes.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, I think Brunelleschi's Dome is truly a work of art. Art is not only about what the final product presents, but the story and background behind the masterpiece. By reading this novel, it gave me the insight and knowledge I needed to fully understand how unique and brilliant this dome is. Art should leave a lasting impression on society and make a statement in its time and I believe that Brunelleschi achieved this in his construction process of his dome. Brunelleschi's faced many highs and lows but ended with a product of beauty and innovation – a work of art.
ReplyDeleteI do believe that Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. It expresses Brunelleschi's genius and creativity, and it demanded skilled and very precise craftsmanship. The dome still towers over Florence today, with its beauty and originality marveled at by people who live there and visitors from around the world.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, Brunelleschi's dome has to be considered a work of art as well as one of the greatest in architecture. He put so much work and so much passion into creating the dome, and I believe something truly is art if a little bit of the artist's personality and their hard work is reflected in their art. It was a beautiful landmark for all to see and for it to have such detail is so awe-inspiring that it has to be one of the most brilliant pieces of art from the period.
ReplyDeleteI do believe that the dome is a piece of art. I believe this because the dome is not necessary for the church, it would still be a perfectly good church without it. Yet the dome was built to be the wonder of Florence and to be aesthetically pleasing therefore it is art. In general art I think is anything that goes above and beyond its functionality and so the dome is art. John Walsh 154088
ReplyDeleteI think that Brunelleschi’s dome is in fact, a work of art. Brunelleschi created a structure that is not only an excellent feat of engineering, but also aesthetically pleasing. The dome is considered inspirational even to this day. We know this because people continue to visit and discuss it. To me, art is something that makes you stop and think. It is something that makes you want to know more about it, and to understand its creator’s intentions. Art continues to inspire wonder and awe in those who view it. Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art because it is and has all of these features.
ReplyDeleteI do believe that Brunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. Its construction is unique in comparison to the other domes and buildings of its time. And it is obviously a tourist attraction for a reason. Its height and beauty simply amazes those who see it, and not only does it look pretty from the outside, but the artwork on the inside is beautiful as well. Brunelleschi's Dome is an inspiration to people everywhere.
ReplyDeleteArt is defined as the quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance. Althought this dome may not be like the paintings and drawings we consider art, the dome is actually a work of art. I believe that his dome is a work of art because Brunelleschi constructed this dome in a sophisticated way that was very difficult but in the end the product was what a definition of art is, beautiful, appealing, and of more than ordinary significance.
ReplyDeleteBrunelleschi's Dome is a work of art. It's almost impossible structure is physical evidence that it truly is miraculous. The way it was built and the intricate detail that went into creating it is amazing and is held in a high regard in my mind.
ReplyDeleteTo me, Brunelleschi's Dome is definitely a work of art. The ideas he had and planned to utilize seemed impossible to many people, but he completed the dome proving his doubters wrong. According to me, art is when a person creates a piece of imagination and at completion, people are in awe of its beauty and creation. Under that definition, the Dome is with no exception a work of art. Brunelleschi was remarkably ahead of his time in architecture, influencing many generations to come to be interested in his works.
ReplyDeleteI think that Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. It is art because it's beautiful and something created my hand. A dome is probably not what most people think of as art, but it's just a different form of it. He put forth so much planning and effort and that also makes it art. To me, art is a form of expression based on the person creating the artwork. Art is what you make it.
ReplyDeleteFilippo Brunelleschi's passion and creativity for art is shown in the dome of the cathedral, Santa Maria del Fiore. It has dominated the city of Florence for over five centuries and continues to thrive. The creation of the dome brought about many new technologies and inventions that has affected the world today. Many still climb to the top of the dome, "to gain a panoramic view of the city" (163). Also, the dome's beauty and grace can be seen from miles away for all to enjoy. Although there were countless obstacles and hardships, Brunelleschi's dome is a masterpiece and true work of art.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion, Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. There are many definitions of art, but I do believe that Brunelleschi's dome definitely fits one of them. Even though when people think of art, most likely they are thinking of a painting, but because of the amount of effort and creative ability put into this maginificent dome, it truly is art. I believe that anything that requires creative effort should be considered art, no matter if it is the Mona Lisa or a finger painting done by my little brother. Falling high in my standards, Brunelleschi's dome is truly a piece of art.
ReplyDeleteI think that Brunelleschi's dome is a work of art. I think that art can be defined as many different things, so you can't necessarily say that something is completely not art. Brunelleschi's dome is truly art because of all the scientific knowledge it required to stay standing. It is also amazing art because of the creativity that was required to build the dome.
ReplyDelete